You know that feeling when you're watching a show and one specific actor just grounds the entire thing? That was Erick Avari for The Chosen. It’s wild because he was only in the first season, yet if you ask any fan about their favorite moments, they almost always bring up that rooftop scene. Honestly, it's kinda rare for a character to leave such a massive void when they depart, but Avari’s Nicodemus did exactly that.
He wasn't just another guy in a robe. He was the emotional anchor.
What Really Happened with Erick Avari and The Chosen?
Let’s clear something up right away: there wasn't some behind-the-scenes drama or a falling out with Dallas Jenkins. It's actually much simpler, though maybe a little sad for those of us who wanted him to stay forever. Basically, Erick Avari was already retired when the role of Nicodemus came across his desk. He had spent decades in Hollywood—you’ve definitely seen him in Stargate, The Mummy, or Independence Day—and he was pretty much done with the grind.
But the script for The Chosen changed his mind. He saw something in the character of Nicodemus that felt different. He came out of retirement specifically for this project, which is a testament to how much he cared about the story.
The Mystery of the Season 1 Exit
When Season 1 ended with Nicodemus weeping because he couldn't bring himself to follow Jesus on the road, fans were devastated. We all expected him to pop back up in Season 2. And Season 3. Then Season 4.
He didn't.
The reality is that his arc for that specific portion of the story was complete. In the show’s narrative, Nicodemus was a man trapped by his status and his "old life." Avari played that struggle so perfectly that his absence felt like a physical weight in the following seasons. He went back into his quiet life, leaving the door slightly ajar but mostly just enjoying his retirement.
Why His Portrayal of Nicodemus Mattered
Usually, in biblical movies, the Pharisees are just flat, one-dimensional villains. They’re "the bad guys" who yell a lot. But Avari didn’t do that. He gave us a Nicodemus who was curious, terrified, and deeply spiritual. He made us realize that the stakes for a man of his stature weren't just religious—they were social, financial, and personal.
You can see it in his eyes during the "Born Again" conversation. It’s not a lecture; it’s a desperate man trying to understand if his whole life has been a lie.
That Shocking ChosenCon Moment
Fast forward to late 2025. If you were following the news or attended ChosenCon, you know things got electric. For the longest time, everyone assumed Avari was done. Then, the production team dropped a bombshell about his return.
Seeing him back in the mix—even if it’s just to wrap up the character's journey toward the crucifixion—felt like a reunion with an old friend. It’s the kind of fan service that actually works because the character is so vital to the Gospel of John.
The "Retirement" Question
People keep asking: Is he officially back for good?
Kinda, but not really. Avari is very selective. He’s 73 now and has been very vocal about the fact that he doesn't need to work. He does this because he loves the craft. When he showed up at Pensacon recently, he mentioned he’s mostly retired but keeps a "never say never" attitude toward projects that have actual soul.
It’s a different vibe than most actors who are constantly hunting for the next paycheck.
Common Misconceptions About Erick Avari and the Show
- He left for health reasons: Not exactly. While he did have an injury way back in 2013 during a stage production (Bunty Berman Presents...), his departure from The Chosen was purely narrative and personal choice.
- He was too expensive: While he’s a high-caliber actor, the show’s creators have always said they’d find a way to make it work if the story required him.
- He didn't like the direction of the show: Actually, he’s been one of the show's biggest cheerleaders, often speaking about how much the set felt like a family.
What This Means for Season 5 and Beyond
With the story moving toward Jerusalem and the eventual trial of Jesus, Nicodemus has to be there. The Bible places him at the burial, bringing a massive amount of myrrh and aloes. It’s a huge moment.
Knowing Avari is involved again means we’re going to get a payoff for that Season 1 heartbreak. We’re going to see the "Secret Disciple" finally step into the light.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
If you want to catch up on Avari’s best work outside of the robes, check out these deep cuts:
- Stargate (1994): He plays Kasuf, and he’s basically the heart of the film.
- The Mummy: He’s the museum curator, Terrence Bey. It’s a classic "Avari" role—smart, slightly stressed, and memorable.
- Hachi: A Dog’s Tale: It’ll make you cry, but his performance is top-tier.
If you’re waiting for more Nicodemus, keep an eye on the official The Chosen app releases for Season 5. The production has been tight-lipped about the exact episode count for Avari, but his presence is confirmed to be more than just a quick cameo. It’s a full-circle moment for a character who started the whole "Who is this man?" journey for the audience.
Go back and re-watch Season 1, Episode 7. Look at the way he handles the silence. That’s the masterclass you’re paying for when you bring a guy like Erick Avari onto your set.